Friday, January 24, 2014

A Funny Thing Happened: On Justin, Violence, and Memes


I was told to “lighten up” today.  Indeed, there are things about which I may need to lighten up, but let me tell you about one that I do not need to lighten up about.

We all know that Justin Bieber was arrested on various charges this past week.  There has been a meme circulating on social media that has Justin’s mug shot with the lyric “as long as you love me” superimposed.  On the other half of the meme there is a picture of a menacing looking man in the same type of orange jumpsuit that Justin is wearing with the words, “Oh, I’m gonna love you.” 

I am not going to apologize for not liking and for objecting to sexual violence or, in this meme’s case, implied sexual violence jokes.  This isn’t funny.  Justin may have lots of problems; he may be a pseudo-musician; he may be an over privileged punk who is running amuck.  He is a celebrity, yes, but more than that he is a human being.  And, like any other human being, he does not deserve to be the victim of sexual assault.  Whatever you think of him, I bet if you stop and think for one second, you will agree that while he needs to answer for breaking the law, he certainly doesn’t deserve sexual violence.  Put your best friend’s, your brother’s, your cousin’s, your son’s picture in there instead of Justin’s – still laughing?  By posting and giggling about this kind of post, you are conceding that sexual violence should serve as part of a punishment for running afoul of the law.  

If your response to that last sentence is anything like “Well, yeah, too bad, that punk deserves what he gets” or “It’s all in good fun.”  Then, I suppose you think if a woman dresses in a certain way she deserves to be raped.  That’s funny, right?  How about if a young woman on a college campus drinks too much, does she “deserve” a sexual assault?  Hilarious. Did you know that “[seven] percent of male students [have] admitted to committing or attempting rape, and nearly two-thirds of them said they had done so multiple times — six on average”?  Are you laughing?

The situations are different, but the implication is the same: if a person does certain things, then he or she deserves sexual violence.  If a celebrity breaks the law, he should answer for that just as anyone else should.  Does he deserve to be raped or otherwise violated in prison?  According to a 2012 Justice Department study, “nearly one of every 10 state prisoners is sexually victimized during confinement.”  (Cited article.)  Is that really funny?

Rather coincidentally, this meme was posted on the same day that President Obama created a task force to make a study of sexual violence on college campuses and gave that task force 90 days for the study and to “to recommend best practices for colleges to prevent or respond to assaults, and to check that they are complying with existing legal obligations.” (You can read about this task force here.)

Sexual assault is a problem among all populations – women, men, gay, straight; and, in all areas – rural, urban, suburban, college campuses.  I would posit that the president can create as many task forces as he likes and review as many best practices as he wants, but that will change precious little when there are significant segments of America that thinks sexual violence is just what happens in prison, or just what happens when a girl gets drunk at college, or is just that funny. 

Nope, I’m not going to lighten up about this.

I am not laughing.




No comments:

Post a Comment